91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Hero Image
91
Lake Shore Drive
West Brookfield | Massachusetts

Where Iron

Ornaments Elegance

View More
Menu
Katie Mulcahy
Katie Mulcahy
Presented At
$930,000
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
4
Living
2,861
SQFT
Library
Office
Air Conditioning
Washer Dryer
Bar
Walk In Closet
Jacuzzi
Basement
Terrace
Garage
Garden
Balcony
Water View
Lake View
Lakefront
Waterfront
Renovated
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 1
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 2
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 3
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 4
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 5
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 6
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 7
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 8
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 9
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 10
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 11
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 12
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 13
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 14
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 15
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 16
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 17
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 18
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 19
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 20
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 21
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 22
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 23
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 24
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 25
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 26
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 27
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 28
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 29
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 30
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 31
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 32
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 33
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 34
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 35
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 36
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 37
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 38
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 39
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 40
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 41
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 42
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 43
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 44
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 45
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 46
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 47
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 48
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 49
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 50
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 51
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 52
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 53
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 54
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 55
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 56
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. - Photo 57
Thumbnail 1
Thumbnail 2
Thumbnail 3
Thumbnail 4
Thumbnail 5
Thumbnail 6
Thumbnail 7
Thumbnail 8
Thumbnail 9
Thumbnail 10
Thumbnail 11
Thumbnail 12
Thumbnail 13
Thumbnail 14
Thumbnail 15
Thumbnail 16
Thumbnail 17
Thumbnail 18
Thumbnail 19
Thumbnail 20
Thumbnail 21
Thumbnail 22
Thumbnail 23
Thumbnail 24
Thumbnail 25
Thumbnail 26
Thumbnail 27
Thumbnail 28
Thumbnail 29
Thumbnail 30
Thumbnail 31
Thumbnail 32
Thumbnail 33
Thumbnail 34
Thumbnail 35
Thumbnail 36
Thumbnail 37
Thumbnail 38
Thumbnail 39
Thumbnail 40
Thumbnail 41
Thumbnail 42
Thumbnail 43
Thumbnail 44
Thumbnail 45
Thumbnail 46
Thumbnail 47
Thumbnail 48
Thumbnail 49
Thumbnail 50
Thumbnail 51
Thumbnail 52
Thumbnail 53
Thumbnail 54
Thumbnail 55
Thumbnail 56
Thumbnail 57
91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States. , West Brookfield , Massachusetts 01585

Lakefront Masterpiece Blends Architectural Brilliance With Effortless Elegance

Stunning 2800+sq ft custom lakefront home overlooks 51 feet of private shoreline on Lake Wickaboag in picturesque West Brookfield, Massachusetts. Completely renovated in 2005, this waterfront masterpiece blends open architectural brilliance with effortless elegance to maximize natural light and lake views from almost every room. Inside, you are met with soaring cathedral ceilings, open riser staircases, and dramatic floor-to-ceiling glass that frames the lake like art. The chef’s kitchen is incredible with granite countertops, custom cabinetry, an oversized island, and stainless appliances—all open to the dining area and sun-drenched living spaces. A striking sunroom invites you to lounge lakeside year-round, while the cozy library with bay window and custom-built-ins offers a quiet escape. A main-level lakeview convertible office provides unique integrated living. Upstairs, the cathedral-ceiling primary suite is complete with a balcony, French doors, a walk-in closet, and breathtaking lake views. A guest bedroom and loft offer space and comfort for visitors. The finished walkout lower level features a wet bar, den, and access to a 3-season porch—perfect for lakeside entertaining. Outside, enjoy terraced decks, a hot tub gazebo, lush gardens, and direct lake access. Offered fully furnished, this rare sanctuary is ready to be your luxurious year-round residence or weekend escape.

Gallery

3D Street View Tour

Map showing 91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States.

Property Location

91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States., West Brookfield Massachusetts

Local Weather & Climate

West Brookfield, Massachusetts

Current Conditions Updated recently
72 °F
Overcast clouds
Feels Like 71°F
Humidity 56%
Wind 11 mph
Visibility 6.2 mi
Sunrise 10:32 AM
Sunset 11:12 PM
5-Day Forecast
Wed 1 Apr
Rain
High 69°
Low 60°
Thu 2 Apr
Rain
High 52°
Low 36°
Fri 3 Apr
Clouds
High 65°
Low 36°
Sat 4 Apr
Clouds
High 64°
Low 48°
Sun 5 Apr
Clouds
High 57°
Low 39°
Data from OpenWeatherMap

Walkability & Transit Scores

How easy is it to get around West Brookfield?

Walkability and transit scores for this address come from the EPA National Walkability Index.

Mortgage Calculator

Estimate your monthly payments for this property

$
%
$100,000
%
Estimated Monthly Payment $3,160
Monthly Payment Breakdown
Principal & Interest $2,528
Loan Amount $400,000
Total Interest $337,621
Total Cost $737,621
Potential Tax Benefits (United States)
$0 Est. First Year Interest Deduction
$0 Est. Annual Tax Savings
*Based on post-2017 tax law. Actual deductions depend on filing status, itemization, and current tax laws.

Ready to explore financing?

Connect with trusted mortgage partners

Important Information
  • This calculator is for illustrative purposes only and does not constitute a loan offer, pre-approval, or commitment to lend.
  • Monthly payment estimates do not include property taxes, homeowner's insurance, HOA fees, or other applicable costs which may significantly increase your actual payment.
  • Interest rates shown are for demonstration only. Actual rates depend on your credit score, down payment, loan type, property location, and current market conditions.
  • This tool provides estimates only. Consult with a licensed mortgage professional for accurate quotes and personalized advice.
  • Tax benefit calculations are simplified estimates based on general assumptions for United States. Actual deductions depend on your specific tax situation, filing status, and current tax laws.
  • Tax Year Information: Tax data shown is based on United States tax year 2025 (fiscal year: January-December), rules effective from 2018 through 2025. Tax laws change frequently and may have been amended since this data was compiled.

Market Opinion

Above Average 2.4× median

Our perspective on current market conditions in West Brookfield. For informational purposes only — always consult a licensed real estate professional before making decisions.

Good Time to Buy
Market conditions favor buyers. Consider making a move.
70
Buyer Score
Prices are down 23.2% year-over-year
Homes are taking 70 days to sell - more time to negotiate

Local Market Price Trends

Median home sale prices in West Brookfield, Massachusetts — ZIP code 01585 over the last 24 months. This shows how property values in this neighborhood have changed over time, helping you understand whether the market is appreciating, stable, or cooling.

This property is listed at $930,000
Area median: $379,950
-23.2% year-over-year (well below the 3.5% historical avg)

Market Competition

70 days
Days on Market
Above typical
99.9%
Sale-to-List Ratio
Below asking

Future Value & Wealth Building

Starting investment: $930,000 20% down ($186,000)

42.4 years
Double Your Investment
Based on current market trends, your property value could double
$456,796
10-Year Equity
Your potential equity after 10 years of payments and appreciation
$4,950
Monthly Investment
Estimated monthly mortgage payment (principal & interest)
$1,519,016
30-Year Wealth Potential
Total equity after full mortgage payoff with market appreciation
2.5x
Leverage Power
Your $186,000 down payment could grow to $456,796 in equity (10 yrs)
Investment Perspective
$ $ $
$1 → $1.18
Every dollar invested today could become $1.18 in 10 years
$100 → 118 $1,000 → $1,178
+$42
$42/day
Your home may appreciate while you sleep
$295/week $1,278/mo $15,335/yr
$100K Investment Comparison (10 Years)
Real Estate (Leveraged)
$189K
S&P 500 Index
$259K
High-Yield Savings
$155K
Real estate leverage: potential -27% advantage over stocks
RENT 💸 -$512K
vs
OWN 📈 +$457K
$457K Potential Equity
vs $512K lost to rent over 10 years
$186K Down Payment Growth
2.5x
10yr
$457K
4.6x
20yr
$864K
8.2x
30yr
$1.5M
Wealth Comparison
×4
Equivalent to 4 average US homes
top 10%
US household wealth ranking
Median: $193K Yours: $1.5M
Time to Double Your Investment (accounting for market cycles)
60.5
years
Conservative
1.15% effective/yr
26.6
years
Optimistic
2.64% effective/yr
Projected Home Values (adjusted for market cycles)
10 Years
Conservative $1.0M +12%
Market $1.1M +18%
Optimistic $1.2M +30%
$457K est. equity
20 Years
Conservative $1.2M +26%
Market $1.3M +39%
Optimistic $1.6M +68%
$864K est. equity
30 Years
Conservative $1.3M +41%
Market $1.5M +63%
Optimistic $2.0M +119%
$1.5M est. equity

Historical Market Context

How current appreciation compares to long-term averages

National Long-Term Average
4.27 %
1967 – 2024
57 years of U.S. home price data
Recent Decade Average
6.5 %
2014 – 2024
Post-recovery bull market
Opportunity Zone
Current 2.5% appreciation is below the national historical average. This market may offer value opportunities.

Projections account for historical market cycles (~12% corrections every 6 years). Effective annual growth after corrections: 1.6%. Market scenario reflects current 2.5% YoY trend from Redfin (May 2026). These projections are estimates only and actual results may vary. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Data from U.S. Census Bureau, World Bank, Zillow, and Redfin | Market data updated May 2026

Neighborhood Demographics

ZIP 01585 • 2022 ACS Data

4,841 Population
Median Age: 52.0
$69,767 Median Income
Average
$286,900 Median Home Value
Rent: $1,105
26.3% College Graduates
Average

Housing

Homeowners 70.7%
Renters 17.5%
Vacancy Rate 11.8%

Employment

7.0% Unemployment
15.8% Work From Home

Education Attainment (Age 25+)

High School+ 91.9%
Bachelor's+ 26.3%
Graduate+ 9.5%
Data from U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey 2022

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about this property

This house at 91 Lake Shore Drive , West Brookfield, MA 01585, West Brookfield, Massachusetts, United States features 3 bedrooms with 2,861 square feet of living space.
This property offers 2,861 square feet of living space.
This property is listed at $93,000,000, which equals $32506 per square foot.
In West Brookfield, home prices have decreased 23.2% over the past year, homes typically sell within 70 days, it's currently a unknown. These market conditions can affect pricing strategies and negotiation opportunities.
Based on current market indicators, West Brookfield shows an active market. The market opportunity score is 70 out of 100, reflecting factors like price trends, inventory levels, and days on market.
This is a house located in West Brookfield, Massachusetts. The property is situated in an established neighborhood with convenient access to local amenities and services.
Katie Mulcahy

Katie Mulcahy

Mathieu Newton Sotheby's International Realty

View Full Profile

Schedule a Tour

Get in touch with our listing agents

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat

More Listings

Explore more properties

Official Real Estate Games

Have fun discovering more properties while playing our real estate games — win prizes for ranking high!

$
$
$
$
$
$
$
WIN CREDITS
Up Your Real Estate Skills FOR FREE

Loading listings...